I asked a second opionion, or I should say the opinion from the man himself regarding Lag’s comment on right arm/hand stuff…here is the ogrinial quote for reference:-
Hi KOC,
Don’t have time to get involved on that site, but you might want to post this in my behalf as some Yoda “guidance from afar.”
Regarding lagpressure’s most recent post (Oct 22 at 10:52 pm), he is referring to the Homer Kelley quote (from 1-F): “And variations in Elbow Bend and/or location during Release will disturb Clubface control by the Right Arm, making it an inferior procedure.”
Unfortunately, lagpressure has completely missed the boat when he states:
“His [Homer’s] quote is clearly referring to release… which your altered definition seems to drift from. In this context I completely agree with Homer… Straightening the ELBOW which would lead me to believe this is referring to DRIVING THE RIGHT FOREARM through release… IS NOT AN IDEAL METHODOLOGY.”
In no way was that Homer’s intent. In fact, one of the major concepts presented in 1-F is the use of the Right Arm and Hand to sense and control ClubHEAD acceleration.
Let’s set the facts straight:
In the posted quote from 1-F, Homer is directly referencing CLUBFACE CONTROL by the right arm and the reason why using it for that purpose is inferior. Instead, the alternative use of the Left Wrist (and its Hinge Action Control) is much preferred.
Homer tried for a long time to put Clubhead and Clubface control in the same hand – left or right, he didn’t care – but found that the assignments must be divided between the two hands: the Left for ClubFACE control and the right for ClubHEAD control.
That’s why he says in 1-F:
“You will save yourself much anguish by using the Right Hand just for sensing and controlling acceleration and the Left Hand just for sensing and controlling alignments. Right Hand – Clubhead. Left Hand – Clubface.”
He said that because he himself had already “anguished” plenty over the problem (of putting both Clubhead and Clubface control into one hand or the other) and found it couldn’t be done. At least not as effectively.
Homer emphasized that fact when he further stated in 6-B-1-0 (First Power Accumulator) that the Right Elbow is responsible for the activities of the #3 Accumulator Motion . . .
“. . . but not the actual Clubface aligning”.
Here he references his comment in 1-F. So clearly, that was his intention with his “inferior procedure” statement in 1-F.
Finally, see also 2-H where he is discussing the Right Shoulder:
“Variations in its Impact location will vary the Right Elbow’s Impact Bend and so may alter the Impact Alignment of the Clubface.”
Hope this helps to put things back on track.
End quote.